Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Should they be able to take your work without paying you or your company?

If this were the beginning and end of the issue, you'd be arguing from a strong position. However, holding up theoretical harms by Z-Library (*=lost sale) while omitting the actual, massive and continual harm done against creators (against everyone really) by predatory publishers - it's cursing the puddle while ignoring the tsunami.



Predatory publishers? Please. Self publishing has never been easier. Authors can keep 100% of the revenues if they choose. The fact that they willfully sign away large percentages just reflects the reality that printing, design, editing, distribution and sales are expensive.


> Predatory publishers? Please. Self publishing has never been easier.

> The fact that they willfully sign away large percentages just reflects the reality that printing, design, editing, distribution and sales are expensive.

You can try to paint academic, research, technical and professional papers authors with that brush. I think you'll find they strongly disagree with that characterization and are fairly tired of pushing back on it.

They publish where their careers mandate. The publishers who own those journals know those authors don't have any meaningful choice. Not that that stops the flow of industry talking points and mischaracterizations.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: