Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I have four active email users in my free "legacy edition" vanity domain workspace.

I am not willing to pay USD4x6x12 per year to have this continue to work. Looking around for the most affordable alternative for four active email accounts brings me to... Microsoft! Microsoft 365 Family Edition. Like a lot of salary drones I use Microsoft products at work, so I get a discount.

It is sad to be paying for full Microsoft Office capability only to not use it, only to keep my email addresses working. It seems positively bizarre, from the view of 20 years ago, to be fleeing from Google to Microsoft. But the fact remains, CAD$76.xx or so per year is something I can stomach for email address continuity for four people. Well, maybe the terabyte of cloud storage per user could come in handy for (encrypted) cloud backups as well.

If you can't get the employee discount, googling suggests the best deal for M$365 Family in Canada is: Costco! $99 for 15 months.

Anyone else find something good for four users? A colleague has Fastmail for CAD$46/year (paid multiple years in advance). I'd love to use that, but for four users... too expensive again.



Apple's iCloud+ is cheaper. I pay $1/mo ($12/year) and that covers a few domains and a handful of email addresses with 50GB of storage. $3/mo ($36/year) will get you 200GB of storage and a family plan that lets you set up different accounts with different logins.

I think Microsoft 365 is a great value if you're looking for everything it offers - it includes Office, 1TB of storage per user, etc. Oh, one downside of Microsoft 365's custom domain email is that you have to use GoDaddy as your registrar: "Domain sold separately. You must maintain an active domain with GoDaddy to use this feature" (https://www.microsoft.com/en-gb/microsoft-365/p/microsoft-36...). So if you're using Cloudflare and paying $7.85 for a .com and need to move it to GoDaddy at $18.99, that's another $11.14/year, $0.93/month to use Microsoft 365.

I moved my email over to iCloud+ and I've been happy. It was easy to set up and pretty cheap at just a dollar.

Zoho is another option. $1/mo per user with 5GB of storage. It's less storage than iCloud+ and more money (and it's annual billing, not monthly), but you might like it better. Zoho also has a free plan that doesn't include IMAP access (and lets you use custom domains).

Note, these prices are USD. iCloud+ is $1.29 CAD for 50GB and $3.99 CAD for 200GB.


The problem I have with iCloud+ is that it is tied to family group, and my own nuclear family is 7. Let alone all the extended family using my domain.


A quick google suggests that you can use/administer iCloud through the web and can access email through IMAP (though not POP).

But can it do four different users (Apple IDs) all getting email through the same vanity domain?


Good luck with that. For home accounts, you’re tied to GoDaddy. Or rather Microsoft via GoDaddy? Who knows. I would NEVER use GoDaddy after reading various experiences around the net.

Also, no aliases. Are multiple domains even possible?


Their help admittedly is professional-tier centric and suggests that if you can edit your DNS record to add the "I own this" file they give you, you can use any domain. Do they explicitly not support this for the family edition? I guess I'll have to test it with a free month and a spare domain.


The FAQ explicitly answers this question:

> Q: I already own a domain that's registered with a provider other than GoDaddy. Can I set up a personalized email address in Outlook.com? > > A: At the moment, we only support connecting domains managed by GoDaddy with Outlook.com.

There’s not a lot of room for workarounds here. If you read some help, be extra careful it’s not for Microsoft 365 business, which offers a lot more freedom. For a price.


I've just moved a small business (25-50 users) off of GoDaddy 365.

Every horror story about other GoDaddy products is equally applicable to their 365 offering.

Their support takes hours to get to, and has hung up on us multiple times when the problem is anything but wanting to purchase more services, putting you back at step 1.

They force you into their own god awful auth instead of Microsofts usual OAuth and it breaks so many things, making you sign in constantly and you can't even use 2FA.

For anyone reading this, never use GoDaddy 365, I am so glad to be free of it.


M365 family doesn't let you manage users as part of one "organisation" in the same way that Google Apps does. It's effectively 6 copies of M365 Personal. And you can only add a vanity domain if you happen to manage it with GoDaddy. The closest to G-suite is M365 Business Basic which is cheaper than G-suite and only includes web and mobile versions of the Office suite, but it does come with 1TB of storage per user which is nice.

As someone else mentioned - the cheapest per user hosted service that is close in functionality to G-suite is Zoho.

I know all this because I've also been bitten by the impending decommissioning of free G-suite so did a bit of research yesterday. I've signed up with M365 Business Basic and am in the process of moving my domains over to it now. I only need one mailbox but I have a bunch of domains and email aliases that I manage.

(edit - changed "Starter" to "Basic")


Zoho Mail si probably the cheapest you can find for limited users and custom domains


I've given this some serious thought and I'm considering using Cloudflare Email Forwarding [https://www.cloudflare.com/apps/email-forwarding].

This will allow one to continue to collect usual emails/mailinglists, albeit forwarded to your other personal gmail (for example) account.

The only downside I see is that replies to any emails will originate from the redirected email address.


https://www.namecheap.com/hosting/email/

Mid-level tier is just under $60/year for 4 mailboxes, custom domain name, and, if desired, catch-all email. Reasonably good webmail, as well as SMTP/IMAP/POP3 options.


You might want to consider iCloud+ as well. It starts at $1 / month.

You get 50 GB of storage, custom email domain, etc...


iCloud price is affordable. One problem I noticed, though, is the process to create a family account. You must have an Apple device to do it. There is no option to do it through the browser. I don't have an Apple device, so I cannot create a family group associated to my individual account.


I was subscribed to paid g suite for more than 2 years and only used custom domain email. When Apple released iCloud+ [0] or whatever it is called, I immediately migrated there and am really happy with it.

You will probably need to subscribe to some iCloud plan and have an apple device. But if you already use those, you are good to go.

[0] https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT212514


Does iCloud+ support wildcard catch-alls?


No :( And it has a 3 address limit per user + domain which is annoying.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: