Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I don't know who downvoted you - you're absolutely right regarding the human ability to influence others. You didn't word it well, but the core of what you're saying is completely correct.

I've never been able to watch any Bill Hicks routine because that's the first one I saw, and it shocked me with how needlessly ugly it was. I can't find that stuff funny. Suggesting people kill themselves for their profession... That's fucked up.



I think that you should take a comedians word with a grain of salt.

What Bill Hicks was literally getting at was that to use your talent as a wordsmith to create wants where there are none and to pursue money without any consideration for ethics by trying to translate each and every human emotion into the dollar equivalent and a 'hook' by which to gain acess to peoples wallets is a very wrong thing.

Comedians will exaggerate grossly in order to make their point. See Carlin, Connolly and many others for more examples of such behaviour.

It's up to us to separate out the core facts from the poetic license.

The kind of marketing that the great-grandfather post of this comment referred to is exactly the wrong way to use marketing.

There is a book by some guy called 'how to win friends and influence people', it is a great example of how not to use skills with words, it is simple manipulations and there is a world of a difference between manipulation and reasonable discourse between consenting parties.

The latter is what sets us - amongst many other things - apart from the animals, not our ability to 'market' or to 'sell' where no need exists.

Marketeers now routinely employ psychologists in order to learn better which of our buttons they should push in order to get access to our innermost feelings so that we go and do what they want, consume their product.

For a nice example have a look at this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hi63rXnuWbw

And tell me what you think of that.


A more appropriate book would be:

Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion = Robert B Cialdini

I agree with Mr Hicks, using your intelligence to find ways to psycologically manipulate people is pretty low.


Comedians will exaggerate grossly in order to make their point.

In other words, they improve their marketing. How ironic.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: