Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Matt, good fellow that you are, this post had many excellent points about the music industry and how last year's executives were incented to not get it.

However, I must take issue with you singling out "intelligent" people for thinking other people with expertise are idiots. I invite you to have a drink (on me) at any sports bar in Toronto and we will trip over people who think that various professional players, coaches, and analysts are idiots.

And likewise if we seat ourselves on any transit bus or train we will have no trouble earwigging a dozen conversations in which people with no experience or expertise in government will denounce their elected representatives as idiots, and then toss in the unelected civil servants as being twice as dumb.

I suggest what you are seeing on HN is a fairly common phenomenon. So while I liked your insight into the executives and their entirely rational behaviour in beating a reluctant and bloody retreat, I take issue with the title.

It's simply Peanut Gallery Disease.



Very good point, and I'll be taking you up on that whenever I get back to your lovely city.


I look forward to it. And by the way... The people second-guessing Toronto's Mayor David Miller? Obviously they're idiots!


So well put it hurts. Bravo.


It's not a disease. If I couldn't talk about things I don't understand, I couldn't talk about anything. Being involved is more fun.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: