Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> I wish there were a Linux machine with the hardware quality of a MacBook

It really depends what you mean by "quality". To me first and foremost quality I look for in a laptop is for it to not break. As I'm a heavy desktop user, my laptop is typically with me on the couch or on vacation. Enter my MacBook Air M1: after 13 months, and sadly no extended warranty, the screen broke for no reason overnight. I literally closed it before going to bed and when I opened the lid the next day: screen broken. Some refer to that phenomenon as the "bendgate".

And every time I see a Mac laptop I can't help but think "slick and good looking but brittle". There's a feeling of brittleness with Mac laptops that you don't have with, say, a Thinkpad.

My absolute best laptop is a MIL-SPEC (I know, I know, there are many different types of military specs) LG Gram. Lighter than a MacBook too. And every single time I demo it to people I take the screen, I bent it left and right. This thing is rock solid.

I happen to have this laptop (not my vid) and look at 34 seconds in the vid:

https://youtu.be/herYV5TJ_m8

The guy literally throws my laptop (well, the same) down concrete stairs and the thing still just works fine.

The friend who sold it to me (I bought it used) one day stepped on it when he woke up. No problemo.

To me that is quality: something you can buy used and that is rock solid.

Where are the vids of someone throwing a MacBook Air down the stairs and the thing keeps working?

I'm trading a retina display any day for a display that doesn't break when it accidentally falls on the ground.

Now I love the look and the incredible speed of the MacBook Air laptops (I still have my M1 but has its screen broke, I turned it into a desktop) but I really wish they were not desk queens: we've got desktops for that.

I don't want a laptop that require exceptional care and mad packaging skills when putting it inside a backpack (and which then requires the backpack to be manipulated with extreme care).

So: bring me the raw power and why not the nice look of a MacBook Air, but make it sturdy (really the most important for me) and have it support Linux. That I'd buy.





Notice how much the screen wobbles after opening the laptop, around the one minute mark. That does not happen even with the cheapest Macbook Air, that’s the kind of design quality people refer to.

As for light and sturdy, the Netbook era had it all. A shame the world moved on from that.


Counter anecdata.

My wife is the bane of electronic devices.

Phones simply won't survive a week without an industrial case. Screen projectors last as short as a single day.

The only computers that survived her JerryRigEverything levels of abuse are MacBooks+ who routinely fall off tables, stairs, or simply hands.

One even fell off open 90 degrees and rotationally fell right on the far edge at what would be the maximum torque position; there was massive deformation of the lid aluminum but the lid was still flat, the glass had no cracks, and the whole thing perfectly functional.

(note: these are the older designs from the first unibody to the last Intel laptop, not the newer Mx ones)

+ Well, except one, which had an entire pint toppled towards and sloshed right upon the screen which had the liquid slide straight into the exhaust vents. There was an audible poof as the screen went black)


> Where are the vids of someone throwing a MacBook Air down the stairs and the thing keeps working?

For some anecdata, I have:

Stood on mine Poured water on it. Been hit by a car while cycling and fallen on it. Dropped it.

It’s fine. Has a few scratches and a small dent. The predecessor is a 2013 Air which has had a hard life. It’s going great.

A colleague put a piece of a4 paper between keyboard and screen then closed it, squeezed it and cracked the screen. Don’t do that.


I've owned two LG gram laptops. Neither were milspec, but both were really nice. Sure, the screen quality isn't going to win any awards, nor will the speakers, but the light weight, fantastic battery life and snappy performance always get a recommendation from me.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: