Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This app's killer feature for me is that it's actually available on F-Droid, unlike its upstream.

Happy user for many years now, thanks for the support!






been using this for years.. it doesn't have the GCM crap and hence works on de-googlified custom ROMs as well. Surprised how many people don't seem to know about it.

> Surprised how many people don't seem to know about it.

There are a few reasons for that.

1. The link to APK cannot be found on the official site[0], so it needs to be looked up in a search engine.

2. Even when downloading from the site, they try to scare you away with a warning [1]. The reason for warning could be avoided by hosting their own F-droid repo, but they refused it, claiming you can download APK and not listening to reason[2].

Though for people using F-droid can still get Signal through the Guardian repository [3]

Thing about the signal APK and the Guardian one is that, it still have the so called "crap" in the final APK, it just runs a background service when required google services are not detected, causing battery drain for many[4].

The drain could also be avoided by supporting UnifiedPush (it can fall back to FCM when it's detected), but they don't want to do that either[5].

[0] https://signal.org/download/

[1] https://signal.org/android/apk/

[2] https://community.signalusers.org/t/how-to-get-signal-apks-o...

[3] https://guardianproject.info/fdroid/

[4] https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android/issues/9729

[5] https://community.signalusers.org/t/use-gcm-fcm-alternatives...


  > Surprised how many people don't seem to know about it.
I'm pretty sure people just want to be angry. I mean look at how many people are arguing that updating is... bad. I cannot and will not take those people seriously. It's just such a laughable position.

Self-updating too!

[flagged]


So don't update. Problem solved...

There's also a great feature with this too. If you don't update for long enough then my chats won't transmit to a vulnerable device, such as one that is running too old of a version. Now that's a great feature


That's not enough.

The killer feature for me is that molly-im also supports UnifiedPush for notifications instead of just websocket and FCM like upstream Signal.

There is also a signal build in the fdroid repo of the Guardian Project

"fdroid repos" have little to do with what people consider F-Droid, they can host any whatsoever binary.

In fact, that's not a build by the Guardian Project, but (when I tried) a redistribution of Signal's https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android/releases builds.

I'm not sure why they're doing it; anyhow, I'd at least avoid doing the initial installation through that repo, you're trusting an additional party for no gain that I could think of (updates are ok because the signature needs to match the one of the installed version).


which is easily enabled in f-droid: settings > repositories > toggle it on

Didn’t know this was in there, thanks!

Good to know - that would make my life a little easier.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: