Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Ha, see what the unions have to say when you threaten the livelihoods of the poor downtrodden push card operatives, there will be placards and flaming braziers by the front gates before you can blink.


This frankly reads as somewhat sociopathic, not just anti-union.

In 2025 I admire anyone brave enough to take this position: are you independently wealthy?


It's somewhat reasonable given the dire history of UK labour relations in the 1970s. As you say, it's now 2025 and the only people who can get away with that are maybe the train drivers. Everyone else has been casualized.


Come now, trying to talk about UK industry in the 70's without mentioning unions?


Except the post that you were replying to was not, was it? And you were talking in the present tense.

If you think unions have no possible value in 2025 you are either independently wealthy, retired on an excellent pension, or very misinformed. Right now everyone should be considering whether there is a union for them, because what is coming down the pipe is not good.


Nobody here is talking about unions in 2025 except you, the whole post is about the decline of British shipbuilding which happened in the second half of the 1900's, along with a lot of other industry.


Sorry, this is just untrue.

You were responding to a comment that was only talking about contemporary issues, so at least someone was talking about contemporary issues:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45873952

So I responded, quite logically, as if you were talking about unions in a contemporary context. Not least because you replied in the present tense to a comment about the present.


Parent referenced push cart use which is from the article, hence my reply was also intended in that context. For future reference you might want to go a little easier on people rather than coming straight in with the snarky 'you must be independently wealthy' remarks, and make the goal to understand each other.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: