Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Pedaling to make energy to store in a battery that then runs an electric motor seems to get around the best thing about bicycles: their efficiency.

No one is going to do that. It's an electric motorcycle in disguise. Don't even play.



If only there were some way to take all that work of pedaling and efficiently translate it into torque on the rear wheel, right?


like a... drive train or something?

science fiction my good dude.


Wouldn't you be able to pedal at your most efficient rate, and go at whatever speed you want? Like how diesel-electric trains don't actually drive the wheels with the diesel engine, they power an electric motor.

(I've never ridden any kind of e-bike so I don't really know how it works)


Bikes have very efficient transmission systems, so outside of extremes you can pedal at an efficient amount of torque for the rider regardless of say: hitting a big hill. This is doubly so for e-bikes that assist in the pedaling.

This is more akin to a hybrid car, who's gas engine could generate electricity, but in the case of this e-Bike from Rivian, why would you do that? The electric motor is significantly more powerful than a person's legs, outside of the Pro Peleton.

Watch anyone on a Class 3 ebike: they're not pedaling. The bicycle drivetrain is just there to get around regulations, like having a license.

Rivian isn't known for making hyper-efficient electric vehicles. Rivians are MANLY trucks made to do MANLY truck things, like go fast! and go through tires faster!


Trains and large trucks use this setup because a mechanical gearbox would need to be enormous to withstand torques they produce. Bikes don't experience even moderate torques so they can be equipped with 10-20 geared transmissions, which weight under 1 kg.


On my e-bike, with just a standard 7-speed transmission I can pedal at my most efficient rate always; since I have an extra 300W of power available I don't need the super-low gears for climbing.





Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: