Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


Yes, Israel is the one currently banning international journalists from entering Gaza. Hamas has no reason to.


Why doesn’t Egypt allow journalists through the Raffah crossing? Or refugees..?


Because Egypt is under a US-aligned dictatorship at the moment. Most Egyptians are upset at their government about this.


[flagged]


The current dictatorship in Egypt deals with the Muslim Brotherhood in the same way pro-US capitalist dictatorships dealt with communist groups. The Muslim Brotherhood is still very popular in Egypt, and in the last legitimate election won close to 50% of the vote. I don't support them but their views are generally closer to Christian Democracy/socialism than you'd think.

Fact is that Egyptians are opposed to this, just like most other people in Arab or Muslim majority countries are. Their government is authoritarian and just does what suits it best, which in this case is to appease the US.


It's always remarkable how people like you think egyptians are incompetent and incapable of taking actions on their own without a special western nation controlling them.


Well, that doesn't change the fact that Egypt is currently under a US-aligned dictatorship. I'm not saying it's under US-control, just that the current dictator stands to benefit by being in the good graces of the US...despite his people's demands.

Also I don't believe that Egyptians are incompetent and incapable, you're putting words in mouth. It's just easier said than done to remove a dictator from power, especially when the power structure is so entrenched. It took Syria over a decade of civil war to get rid of theirs...

We don't live in a Hollywood film. The French Revolution didn't take a month to transition to a republic...


"Aligned" is doing a lot of work here.

Does some part of the Egyptian government have an interest in doing certain things entirely because of America's influence? Sure. Is that the only reason for their behaviour? Of course not.

I just want people to keep in mind that Egypt (and everywhere else) is full of humans who are just as smart or dumb, brave or cowardly, immoral or righteous, as any other country, and those humans are perfectly capable of deciding to do both good and evil things without blaming it on "america".


rany has given a good answer, but I also want to add that currently the Egyptians only control the Rafah crossing on paper.

In reality, Israel controls the crossing because they have occupied/seized the strip of land in Gaza that is adjacent to the crossing (Philadelphi Corridor). Here's a similar complaint from Egyptian media: https://english.ahram.org.eg/NewsContent/1/1234/550260/Egypt...


Yeah, really no reason.

Because they really love unbiased coverage.

> The journalist told RSF that the threat came from Hamas members who were unhappy with his social media posts. A few days earlier, the reporter — who wishes to remain anonymous — had published a post criticising Hamas, which was facing strong backlash from local protestors exhausted from being subjected to the massacres committed by Israeli forces.

> Due to these threats the journalist deleted his posts, fearing for his safety. At least two other journalists have faced threats and physical attacks for covering the protests against Hamas, which lasted several days. “Detention centres and administrative offices in Gaza have been destroyed,” one journalist told RSF. “So now Hamas’ intimidation tactics consist of direct confrontations with journalists, and the journalists have nowhere to go.”

https://rsf.org/en/gaza-rsf-condemns-hamas-threats-against-j...


Sure but your post is completely unrelated.

We are talking about international journalists not being allowed into Gaza. Your comment is about a local journalist being intimidated by Hamas members.

International journalists are generally allowed to report freely. If there was any intimidation they would be airing it nonstop.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: