Can I ask kind of Scotch you like now? There's probably something out there that I'm just not finding.

EDIT: I'm open to things that I hate on the first sip. In fact that might work best for me.

I'm probably the wrong person to ask, because my tastes are very indiscriminate (I like pretty much all of them) and I'm not that experienced tasting whisky. I had the cask strength Laphroaig (10 yrs) and loved that with just a touch of water. Really wild deep flavours.

Thanks! Have you compared it to the "regular" 10y Laphroaig?

Not side to side! I vaguely preferred it, but I can't say without a blind trial or something.