Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

But, it's got my one 'killer' feature YouTube doesn't have: Background play. And that's enough for me.

Also, I have numerous YT alternative apps installed, plus official YT app, so if I need any of the missing features, then I use one of the other apps that has it. And begrudgingly fall back to official YT when all else fails.



Youtube has it, as long as you're willing to pay. They go out of their way to disable background playback on their mobile website as well.

It's not a missing feature, it's a paywalled feature...


That's why I point it out as a missing feature: It's so basic, and yet it's "premium". I'm also intentionally separating YouTube from YouTube Premium* in terms of features, in which context YouTube is missing the background play feature.

*It may be the same app that you open, but the features are distinctly different, so I treat them as separate apps in my mental model. I would do the same for Spotify, for example.


> It's not a missing feature, it's a paywalled feature...

Diner: "Waiter, this soup is missing salt!"

Waiter: "I am very sorry, salt is only part of the Soup+ package, but you ordered the Soup Essentials package. Would you like to upgrade to Soup+?"




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: