OTR can be trivially faked. So if you have a transcript of me saying "I did not commit the crime.", you can easily manufacture "I did commit the crime." And that's how it should be.
If you have a cipher that produces a stream of good pseudorandom numbers, you can use that as a one time pad. Forging is trivial.
If I remember correctly: For the individual messages OTR uses Diffie-Hellman to exchange the key. That means your dialog partner knows the same key, and could have produced the message, too.