Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

First, let's ignore cryptos because I'm talking about IPO's only (albeit the thread is about cryptos)

"Providing capital to someone does not only occur in the IPO stage. I'm not even sure how to go about refuting that statement; that's... not how finance works anywhere on the planet."

First, I provided that statement in the context of the parent comment. In the equities market, providing capital occurs only in IPOs, not in the secondary market. When you buy Apple stock, you typically are exchanging money with another person who is selling it. You are not providing capital to Apple.

Second, you could've gone about refuting my statement by providing a counter-example. It's that easy. Otherwise you're simply just trying to put me down, and make me look like an idiot, without explaining why.



...What do IPOs have to do with parent argument?

Yes, Apple is not receiving any money if there is a share transaction between two investors (duh?). However, providing capital to public companies or does not only occur in IPOs (edit: even if we restrict that with the clause: in an "equities market").

You're right, I could have provided a counter argument. However, at the same time, you should not make such an absurd, unqualified assertion that other people who lack knowledge and are reading these forums may read and assume to be true.


anything that a person says that he believes to be right (even if mistaken and honestly ignorant) sounds absurd to the person who knows more.

so why not provide an actual counterexample that actually adds value? You still have a chance.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: