Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | pbarthelemy's commentslogin

Globally ? Nope … “by western governments and a few others” is more accurate ( most liberation movements are called terrorist at some point, most French called their internal resistance in WWII terrorists, only to use the same word for groups who fought France in their decolonization (Viet-Minh, FLN)

Terrorism is not even defined in international laws ; the more generic notion is war crime is used. ( not that lexical discussions change much for the civilians of any side who lose their lifes … )


Isn’t that obvious ? “The hamas-run health ministry is reporting 40,000 deaths” is a not-so-subtle way make the number questionable… But some will say mentioning hamas is fair, because it is factually true that it runs the government. No wording is neutral… all newspapers have style guides and guidelines and “elements of language”, the NYT ones for the US-funded destruction of Palestine leaked not so long ago, the ones for Israel counter-terrorism operations by Wikipedia is in the article… (see, no wording is neutral, I guess everyone hates me now )


i think they just hate not seeing a magnet link for the nyt genocide enabling style guide


I bet you felt a real rush of pride after writing that.


Palestinians as foreigners ? Ok, then, thanks ! You just recognized Palestine as a country … ( pro-Israel people can’t have it both ways : denying Palestinian statehood or implying it depending on the issue being discussed…)


We’ll they’re outside the borders of Israel. Open a map made by anyone to check this. I’m glad you understand.


Palestinians are stateless. This doesn't make them less of foreigners.


Palestinians, people that belong to a nation with national borders that exist today, that have remained in the same place for thousands of years, are stateless individuals? That's strange.


They may have nation, but they don't have a state. The basic definition of state is monopoly of violence over a territory and ability to defend it.


Oh that totally sounds like the civilized definition of a State.


I think reflexco meant this as a joke….


No, this is what identity politics is, reducing technical matters to which camp you're in ("your post gives me crypto vibes, scam!!"). Correct me if I'm wrong but I believe this doesn't belong on HN.


No. Broad technical camps are not identity politics, and they're a necessary simplification for making judgements about the massive amount of technical novelty being produced today. I am not going to investigate each crypto scam presented to me for all of its technical details; there are too many of them. It's enough to know it's cryptocurrency-adjacent, and therefore, probably a scam.


Honestly pretty funny that you are so critical of identity politics yet so uninformed about what that term actually means


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: