Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | benjiweber's commentslogin

Something like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Do_Not_Track ? Which failed in part because Microsoft turned it on by default which even further disincentivised publishers from respecting it.


The fix here would be to legally force them to comply with Do Not Track instead of forcing them to post compliant banners


They are not forced to use banners, they are forced to get explicit opt-in permission before tracking users, which can be done in non-obtrusive ways.


Okay, so regard the Do_Not_Track header as explicit opt-out permission


No browser implements it as an explicit one where you have to explicitly specify which businesses you do not which to track you.


They would never do this willingly, because they don't want you to automatically opt out of tracking.

The annoyance of the cookie banners is the entire draw for companies. Its not a downside. They're user-hostile. You are their enemy. Their goal is to wear you down and trick you into opting-in, so they can both track with impunity and follow the law.


>They would never do this willingly

I know, that is why I am saying you would force them to respect Do_Not_Track by law.


No your browser can just… choose not to send cookies. The website publisher has no say in that.


Cookies are the easiest way to keep track of a user, but if browsers regularly stop sending cookies then website operators will just find another method to fingerprint users and then we're back to square one with the law still requiring publishers to receive opt-in approval, but with no requirements on how.


> then website operators will just find another method to fingerprint users

Example: The identifier you get when you pass anti-bot challenges (Cloudflare, Anubis, etc).


That's not a cookie?


It probably is, currently. But even if cookies are not used, the identifier for this type of functionality would still need to be stored somewhere and passed to the server in some way to avoid showing another CAPTCHA to the user.

Whatever mechanism they choose to uniquely identify you, they will insist it's necessary for another purpose and they totally are not piggybacking on it for tracking (e.g. for the CAPTCHA example, they would insist it's absolutely necessary to protect themselves from DDoS).

As another example, they can always respond with HTML where all links themselves are an opaque hash that internally contain "route + your id" when decrypted. Then emphasizing that all links are always different even for same routes to "show they are randomly generated", and saying that they do this because... idk, detecting scraping or something random but plausible-sounding. Or whatever sneaky variation of the `?PHPSESSID=` query param from old times.

(Yeah I know the last example doesn't a lot make sense, I didn't think too hard about it, the point is that they will probably find a way somehow.)


The pen writing without touching is usually a misalignment and fixed by removing and re-inserting (or replacing) the tip ime.


My pen is misaligned with the point on the paper by about 1-2 mm often, and no amount of swiping the side of the pen, etc. could fix it so far.


One of the ways pair programming can be effective is one of the pair keeping more of the big picture in mind. Either thinking about alternative approaches or at least spotting the escalation of commitment to current approach and calling a pause to reflect.


This does a much better job than anything I've seen before. Nice work. It still doesn't generate routes I'd use as they're too circuitous due to the poor cycle infrastructure in the UK. However, it does a good job of highlighting good options and options I didn't even know about.


This is brilliant. I've wanted this so many times and had to awkwardly switch between window being shared instead.


I wouldn't mind switching between windows if I could use the GNOME Activities overview for that. But maybe that is not possible because there is no way to communicate the change in stream size if the windows have different sizes?


Which kernel version has the latest fixes?



The irony of setting up a '“Bureaucracy Mailbox” for any examples any of you see where we might have bureaucracy' while announcing an edict enforced by centralised control to replace autonomous decision making about where & how to work.


This is not the first "we're starting a committee to figure out what to do about there being too many committees" I've seen in my ~7 years here. Makes me laugh every time.


The best is when the top issues the committee finds outlast the committee.


this memo is one for the ages. filled with management speak.


Well the current CEO is an MBA. Post founder, MBA days morph into this


A long time ago I joined Deloitte to set up a local software dev. practice.

A few days in I was invited to join a "bureaucracy reduction taskforce". Someone handed me a literally 12 inch thick stack of paper I was meant to read up on before the first meeting. I gave my regrets and withdrew from the taskforce (there were no repercussions - apparently a few others had noped out as well).


I choose to believe that was a strategy. Invite everybody so they feel included, weed out almost everybody so it's a small group and can maybe get something done


Works fine on Linux if you set useragent to Chrome on Mac.


...which only underscores how pointless this is: if it works in Chrome on MacOS and Windows (https://support.apple.com/en-us/120585), it will also work on Linux, so why exclude Linux?!


I wonder if we'll ever get hdcp on nvidia. As much as I enjoy 480p video from streaming services.


Just download it to your pc. It is better user experience and costs less


Which service goes that low? The ones I know limit you from using 4k, but anything up to 1080p works fine.


Nonsense that a 1080p limit is acceptable for (and accepted by) paying customers.


Depends. I disagree with HDCP in theory on ideological grounds. In practice, my main movie device is below 720p (projector), so it will take another decade before it affects me in any way.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: